Recently, I revisited USA-to-Australia forwarding options – not because it’s any cheaper for us to buy from the US (not anymore… thanks AUD exchange rate, you a-hole) but I was becoming increasingly frustrated with delayed Australian cosmetics releases. As a blogger, it’s a massive disadvantage to be receiving ‘new’ collections 6 months after the rest of the world, if indeed we receive those collections at all.
NB for my Australian readers: I used PriceUSA, which actually purchases on your behalf (cost is then direct deposited or transferred by Paypal) and the service was impeccable – great communication and no sales tax. No affiliation, calm your farm. I also tried ShipItTo but encountered issues ordering from US online retailers, as most require the postage address to match billing address (which defeats the purpose entirely!).
Anywho, I decided to trial the PriceUSA service with a HELLA pricy haul… with my fingers crossed, hoping they didn’t run off with all my moneys.
But then it turned up on my doorstep and all was well in the world of Karima. I know I’m flying to the US in a week but this was for SCIENCE okay… Let’s start with the Tom Ford, yus?
I’ve tried everything on a handful of occasions so I’ll add some first impressions.
Tom Ford – Illuminating Primer // More emollient than the Burberry Fresh Glow Fluid. Smells like decayed rubber but I can look past that.
Tom Ford – Traceless Perfecting Foundation in Fawn // Fawn is actually relatively olive! Hallelujah! It’s about an NC25 in depth and exhibits fabulous longevity and a medium buildable coverage.
Tom Ford – Bronzer in Gold Dust // Hmm not sure how I feel about this one… I dusted it over powdered skin with a Chikuhodo Z4 and it still managed to apply a little patchy. It’s also pulls quite orange on my colouring, and not a Guerlain-orange-but-still-beautiful kinda way. Also random flecks of glitter? On the fence, will report back.
Tom Ford – Cream & Powder Eye Colors in Midnight Sea, Naked Bronze and Black Oyster // The fourth and final shade in the Summer 2015 collection, Golden Peach, was out of stock. All but Black Oyster feature repromotes of previous Cream Color for Eyes eyeshadows but I picked them up anyway because it’s one of my all-time favourite formulas.
I’ve happily worn the creams alone but they’re even prettier when paired with the corresponding eyeshadow. Purely based on first impressions, I’m not sure that the glitter compacts offer as much impact as the glitter shades in the Tom Ford Eyeshadow palettes (Cognac Sable features a superb copper) but I’m pleased to own them all the same.
Now onto the Charlotte Tilbury…
Charlotte Tilbury – Airbrush Flawless Powder in Medium // A decent match for my light to medium skintone but in practice, the coverage is negligible, it acts as a translucent powder. Mutes any serious shine while diffusing the appearance of pores although I’m still partial to my Rouge Bunny Rouge Diaphanous Finishing Powder, time will tell!
Charlotte Tilbury – Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eye Pencil in Bedroom Black // Opaque on first swipe, creamy in texture and a bit of playtime before setting. I am yet to test it for longevity but you’ll be the first to know my verdict 😉
Charlotte Tilbury – Eyes to Mesmerise in Bette and Veruschka // Anything on the market that resembles the Tom Ford Cream Color for Eyes, I must own and test.
So far, I can tell that the Charlotte Tilbury counterparts require an extra layer to develop the same opacity as the Tom Ford creams. Both formulas are rather wet and set slowly – plenty of time to diffuse edges. If you struggle with oily lids, creasing or longevity, I suspect that both Tom Ford and Charlotte Tilbury creams will melt off your eyes – they don’t set to a bulletproof finish.
My dry lids welcome the extra slip; super duper long wearing cream shadows are often problematic on drier skin types, where there is insufficient oils on the skin to aid blending.
MAC – Pro Longwear Nourishing Waterproof Foundation in NC20 // Final wildcard purchase. I am hoping to film a first impressions video on this foundation so I am yet to try it! If you have had the chance to play with this new formula, leave your thoughts in the comments 🙂
Hope you enjoyed the post! I’m not generally one to indulge in haul-types-of-content but I figure this is valuable; by the time I’ve tested a product extensively and compiled a post, the product is old news!
xxkarima
Why is Australia so behind on releases of new makeup? Is the market not strong for purchasing? It seems strange to me bc I would think these companies lose out on money by not releasing in Australia right away?…..any explanations on this? π
Most releases are seasonal.. so normally the xmas release colours don’t particularly match well with our hot season. Vice versa with brights in winter. My assumption is they push them back due to that.
I would imagine it also allows them to stagger their production of stock if they launch in different markets one after the other, rather than all at once. And they will always launch in the biggest / strategically most important markets first.
Potentially, although I think Kylie’s suggestion of seasonal colours is on the money! It could be confusing to the consumer if spring colours are released in Autumn (irritating all the same lol).
x
Australian market is too small… retailers don’t really care about such small markets…
While that may be true, I think the issue in Australia is conflicting seasons, as Kylie suggested below. xx
Hi Karima, I have normal to oily lids and I need to use a primer for cream eye shadows to really stay on me. Chanel ones for example only last 3 hours before creasing. Tom Ford however, even without primer, stays on the whole day without any creasing or fading. I have Naked Bronze and it’s such a joy to use the cream shadow on its own.
I’ve been curious to know how the CT ones compare in wear time compared to TF. I’ve read mixed reviews so far π I’d love to know your thoughts after you’ve had enough play time. Your reviews are always refreshingly honest. Thanks in advance!
Now I’m curious to try Tom Ford cream eyeshadows :D, I do have oily lids, too and am struggeling with cream shadows.
I have really oily lids and other than the T.F. ones I really like the Urban Decay Glide on 24/7 Eyeshadow pencils. They are lovely and don’t budge! (and are a bit more affordable than the Tom Ford ones)
I purchased the entire line of CT shadows and if you ever get a chance to try them, let me know what you think! I’d be very curious to see how they compare to TF on *your* lids π
xx
I look forward to your first impression of the MAC Waterproof Nourishing Foundation! I’ve had my eye on it and would really love to hear your thoughts. Very trusting of your opinion π
I’ll get onto that as soon as I’m back in Sydney π
xx
I LOVE the new MAC foundation. Almost a gel-liquid formula. Good colour match for honey-yellow undertones, medium coverage, satin finish (which STAYS satin on my ridiculous oily skin, yaaaasssssss for oil control) and it just didn’t budge on me. Tiny tube though! X
Uh ohhhh, generally foundations that perform wonderfully on oily skin are a nightmare on me! Fingers crossed!
x
I bought 2 of the CT cream eye shadows, Verushuka and Mona Lisa and find they crease without a primer, also just got the Tom Ford Naked Bronze but no creasing no primer. I think the TF is a superior formula, but the Verushuka colour is so.god.damn.gorgeous. Great haul! Iβd be interested to hear your thoughts on the CT powder, itβs been on my Wishlist for ages now. I got the RBR powder after hearing you on YouTube rave about it and I must say I am in love with it. I donβt think Iβve used another setting powder since xx
Veruschka is SUCH a beautiful shade! I think the formulas are pretty similar although I agree, I had some minor longevity issues with the CT shadows and I have dry lids.
I’ve done some extra thinking on the CT powder versus the RBR and my verdict: I much prefer the RBR. It seems to blur pores very well regardless of foundation, whereas the CT works better over some bases than others.
xx
Add me to list of MAC Nourishing Waterproof Foundation lovers. Bought it because we’re moving to Florida this summer, and I didn’t want my base to be gross. So far I am pleased as punch! Great smooth coverage, doesn’t accentuate pores/lines/etc., no breakouts, and lasts and lasts! Just for kicks I jumped in my pool with it on the other day. While my entire look wasn’t kept flawless, the MAC foundation stayed nice – after 30 minutes of swimming it required some gentle re-buffing and a touch of setting powder, but it was passably good to wear for the rest of the evening. I keep reaching for it and I haven’t even left for the sunshine state yet. Ah well, another excuse to hit MAC again. Interested to hear your verdict.
Wow, that’s nice to hear. Did you purchased your normal MAC colour? I heard that the foundation runs a little lighter hence I ordered NC15 and NC20 (they haven’t arrived yet).
Hey Robin,
I’d love to know what skintype you have? Waterproof foundation sounds amazing, though!
x
Do you mind disclosing how much shipping came to for all these?
It was about 56AUD π x
Hi Karima. Great blog. I’ve been reading it for about six months and am always impressed with your thoughtful, down-to-earth reviews. Nice work!
Thanks Emily! I appreciate your kind words π
x
speaking of TF… you have to try their foundation stick! It’s so glowy and creamy it’s my favorite and definitely better than their fluid traceless foundations.
I picked it up while in the states! Can’t wait to try it!
x
Oh Karima, you enabler you! Those Tom Ford shadows-divine!
Also for future reference, you can get Charlotte Tilbury from nordstroms who ship directly to australia….not sure what the shipping difference would be though.
Ditto for Beautylish.
Shelly is correct, if you’re looking for Charlotte Tilbury alone then Beautylish is the best option.
x
Nordstrom only ships certain brands (won’t ship TF, for example) so it made more sense for me to ship using Price USA π
x
Hey Karima,
Have you tried the CT Light wonder foundation? If so, do you recommend it for combination skin? I’m interested in her primer and magic cream as well, but I thought I should try the foundation first and see π Love the haul, always fun the read or watch . xx
Hey Dedee,
I purchased the Light Wonder foundation in the US and so far it seems lovely but VERY sheer. I would liken it to a tinted moisturiser. It’s also very dewy, so you gotta love a bit of sheen!
x
Can’t wait to hear/read/see what you think of the Charlotte TIlbury purchases!
In the meantime, I’ve purchased the MAC Waterproof nourishing too… lemme say… Perfect shade match (NC35)! I just picked it out of the display and asked the MAC MA to test it on me, she thought it’d be too dark on me — hinting that the shade range wasn’t a direct translation with the other MAC foundations perhaps? — but nope, matched me perfectly (I have asian skin, NARS Stromboli shade normally and hover between NC30-NC35 with MAC concealers. I normally hate MAC foundations, but was keen to give this a go. I have trialled used my fingers, beauty blender and a MAC 217 to apply this foundation, and have to say the third option is the best.works a dream, glides on, looks natural, and easily buffed in. Add in a second layer if spots need extra concealing. Definitely a keeper, and convinced to stock more shades in my kit for clients! Small tube, but a little goes a long way X p.s. I tested the waterproofness by splashing my face with water and dabbing with a tissue… nothing came off!
Hey Marie Lee!
What skintype do you have? I purchased my regular shade despite claims that this formula runs lighter than their usual offering because I’ve heard it can oxidise. I’d prefer a foundation that is a touch lighter as opposed to a touch too dark, anyways.
xx
Here are my thoughts on my recently purchased MAC foundation.. I love it! I am normally an NC20 but had to go to NC25 as it matched much better. NC20 was much too light. The wear is very long lasting on my normal to dry skin. I can still see my pores on my most and cheeks slightly though, but that is ok as I am looking through my magnified makeup mirror. I find it wears much better on meif I use a primer. But..I have only tried it once without one so I will have to,experiment a bit more. The finish on me is satin and is beautiful. I am very happy with this purchase.
***nose not most
***myself not meif
Sorry for typos. I should have checked it better
Hey Valerie!
Thanks for your thoughts! I purchased my regular shade because some people experienced oxidising so hopefully I’ll be okay, fingers crossed.
xx
Oooh Iβm excited about your your Mac foundation review! I normally use Studio Sculpt but Iβve been on the hunt for a new foundation!
Can’t wait to try it and tell you all my thoughts!
x
I’m now quite anxious to try the new MAC base, being a proper foundation junkie.
Apropos of nothing…do any US readers have any idea what happened ro the Rouge Bunny Rouge US website? It seems to have disappeared (sad, bewildered face…)
Just googled the RBR US website and it seems to be back up?
https://us.rougebunnyrouge.com
xx
I would love to hear more about your thoughts on the TF foundation…it doesn’t get good reviews on makeupalley but some beauty bloggers seem to love it. I also can’t wait to hear your review of the new Mac prolongwear…ive been debating purchasing it.
You’ll see the TF Foundation in my next tutorial, where I discuss it further π
x
Hi karima! Can you do a post about suncreens? Most sunscreens tend to break me out. I love organic products. I live in sweden and summer has just begun here, yeey! Lots of love βΊοΈ
Hey Olivia,
I hope to do a post on sunscreens at some point but I need to do a lot of research because the world of sunscreens is very technical!
x
Hey Karima π
I absolutely adore your channel and it just so happens that absolutely that I buy after reading (getting myself tempted) from your blog, suits my skin type. Therefore for me, shamelessfrippers.com = best place to know hot or not (for me).
I have been waittttttting to get my hands on the Tom Ford cream colour eye shadows ever since I read your post ( yeap its been a long wait. too $$$). Now a few months ago I tried their eye shadow in the store, loved it but made the mistake of pushing it to “some other time”…. then they changed their collection. I still have my heart set on “Midnight Violet” & “Platinum”. BUT …
1) I am in a country where they don’t sell Tom Ford Beauty products. therefore I’m getting someone to buy it for me…
2) If it doesn’t click – I’m basically screwed.
If you know absolutely anything about these new products and their formulas – or know someone who does – I would love some feedback.
thank you!
Hey Anji,
Tom Ford has released the cream eyeshadows a few times and apparently some shades are now permanent. I can’t say whether they’re the exact same formula as they were, but I have reviewed them here:
https://shamelessfripperies.com/swatches/cream-eyeshadow-smackdown/
xx